ILS Overview

Insurance Linked Strategies or Insurance Linked Securities (ILS) is the general term for investment opportunities that provide investors access to insurance or reinsurance-related risk and through this offer a return profile that is highly independent from traditional asset classes. In exchange for a risk premium, the investor assumes a contractually defined portion of insurance risk which is often linked to large scale events such as hurricanes, earthquakes, severe convective storms, or other natural or man-made disasters. This arrangement provides a steady return if no predefined event happens; investors, however, may experience losses if a covered event under a specific contract occurs during the investment period.

ILS: History and Motivation

The ILS asset class emerged in the aftermath of several disastrous catastrophic events affecting the United States: Hurricane Andrew (1992, Florida), Hurricane Iniki (1992, Hawaii) and the Northridge earthquake (1994, California). In all events, the insured loss tally exceeded expectations by far, and in some cases even forced insurance companies out of business. 

Historically, capital markets responded by setting up dedicated reinsurance carriers after such market dislocations, such as ACE or XL Insurance after the liability crisis in the mid-80s or the “Class of 1992”, so called mono-line cat reinsurance companies such as Renaissance Re, Partner Re or Tempest Re following Hurricane Andrew. Furthermore, in the mid-1990s, the capital markets developed an alternative to reinsurance balance-sheet capital by offering investors the opportunity to participate directly alongside Reinsurers in their technical business through so-called quota-share agreements (similar to a long-established financing method on the British Lloyd’s market) or to provide reinsurance coverage for individual major events through tradable securities issued in accordance with Rule 144A of the U.S. SEC. The ILS asset class and, with the introduction of 144A securities, the catastrophe bond market was born.

Florida hurricane exposure or California earthquake risk are for most large reinsurance companies a systematic risk as these peak exposures accumulate over many assumed contracts. By transferring part of their peak risks to the capital markets, (re)insurers can better manage large-scale disasters. As a positive side-effect – or often even the main motivation – reinsurers can increase their capital efficiency through such transactions, as the peak risks demand the highest amounts of capital buffer in regulatory or rating agency capital models. If such peak risks are reduced, the lower capital base is used more efficiently across the various other risks on the balance sheet.

From the perspective of the so-called ‘globally well diversified investor’, however, such peak risks constitute a perfect idiosyncratic risk that diversify very well in the portfolio. Hence, by investing in ILS, the investor obtains access to an asset class with attractive risk-adjusted returns that are at the same time only very lowly correlated with traditional financial markets.

The uncorrelated nature of ILS provides a valuable source of portfolio diversification, supports a resilient portfolio construction and such generates enhanced risk-adjusted returns.

The ILS Market

Today, the ILS market has a strong focus on property catastrophe risks in mature insurance markets, particularly in regions with significant insured values prone to natural perils. The peak risk covered consists of U.S. tropical storm, most notably Florida and US East Cost/Gulf hurricane, followed by California earthquake, US severe convective storm, Europe winter-storm or typhoons and earthquakes in Japan. 

While the ILS sector initially focused on natural disasters, the market has gradually expanded to ancillary perils such as mortality, health care expenses, trade credit receivables, motor, terrorism, aviation, marine, energy, crop or even cyber risks. Especially the latter peril may offer a diversification to natural perils but is likely to be more strongly correlated to the broader financial markets and through that jeopardises the low-correlation argument to some extent.

ILS transactions vary: Structures may cover a single peril in a single US state (Texas named storm), a book of a nation-wide carrier (US wind and US earthquake), or broader multi-peril coverage across defined geographies – ranging from specific states, countries, regions, or global portfolios. The parameters that determine a payout may be indemnity-based (i.e., compensating the counterparty for its actual loss), based on market loss figures, or based on physical parameters of catastrophic events.

The insurance risks can be transferred by insurers and reinsurers to the capital market through various instruments. The main structures are cat bonds and collateralized reinsurance. 

Cat bonds are standardized, tradable securitizations of individual reinsurance contracts that have maturities of typically one to four years. The bonds are fully collateralized with collateral held in a segregated trust account and generally invested in high quality, short-duration money market instruments. Returns consist of the collateral yield plus a risk premium for assuming the specific underlying insurance risk.

Collateralized reinsurance, sometimes referred to as ‘private transactions’, are bespoke contracts negotiated between the ceding entity and the investor. In line with the traditional reinsurance renewal cycle, contracts are usually structured as an annual venture. As these are bilateral contracts, there is no secondary market. Like cat bonds, they are fully collateralized and therefore provide a floating return on the collateral and additionally generate a risk premium for taking on the insurance risk.

The ILS market offers a range of investment strategies and approaches, each with distinct risk-return characteristics, liquidity profiles and underlying exposures.

The Cat Bond Market

Cat bonds are securities created by the securitization of reinsurance contracts. They are typically principal-at-risk notes issued in accordance with rule 144A of the United States Securities Act. They can only be purchased by QIBs and typically have a minimum investment of USD 250’000, hence investors interested in this asset class often participate through dedicated ILS funds.

The proceeds from the issuance of the bonds are put in a collateral account and then invested in ‘risk-free’ investments (typically market funds). The collateral is used to support the risk assumed via the reinsurance agreement. The premium paid by the reinsured as compensation for assuming insurance (event) risk and the return on collateral are the two constituents of the (typically monthly or quarterly) coupon payments to the investor. In the event of a loss, the coupon ceases for that proportion of the lost collateral and an equal proportion of the principal will not be returned.

Initial pricing of cat bonds is strongly influenced by the modelling results of a third party risk assessment, often performed by a well-recognised cat modelling firm such as Moody’s (RMS), Verisk (AIR) or Cotality (Corelogic). The offering documentation includes a write-up of the risk and, inter alia, the probabilities associated with a no loss, a partial loss of principal or a full loss scenario.

Most cat bonds have a 3 to 4 year term, with a possible extension period of typically three years to cover for the case that an insurance event has occurred during the risk period that has the potential to cause a loss to the bond, but a final loss quantum has not been ascertained. In reinsurance, it can take several years for all losses to be finally settled after an event and a final figure to be established.

Cat bonds trade frequently on the secondary market and several dedicated broker-dealers put out weekly or monthly indicative price sheets for cat bonds. However, liquidity can decline and spreads may widen during or following major catastrophic event.

The Market of Collateralized Reinsurance

In order to better understand collateralized reinsurance a brief description of traditional reinsurance model is helpful. Traditional reinsurance is essentially the insurance of insurance companies. An insurance company prices its business based on the law of large numbers. If it writes a broad enough portfolio, the loss sustained by the portfolio will tend to the sum of the mean losses sustained by the individual risks in the portfolio. Total risk is therefore spread over a large number of individual risks, each paying its share of the premium. This however fails when a single large correlating event broadly hits the risks within the portfolio at one instant, e.g. an earthquake or a hurricane. It is for these broad impacting events, when the diversification of the portfolio breaks down, that insurers purchase reinsurance.

A reinsurer takes on reinsurance risks from around the world, providing protection for many different perils. A reinsurer therefore spreads its risk across geographic scope and varying perils as well as over time; a reinsurer will, to the extent allowed by their accounting regime, build up reserves in good years to offset losses in bad years.

ILS funds have capital to invest in much the same way as a reinsurer, namely to build a diversified portfolio of large infrequent events in return for earning a premium i.e. an income on the capital allocated to support the portfolio. Whereas this can be done through investing in cat bonds, the diversity of accessible peril-regions can be increased by also investing in collateralized reinsurance. Most of the cat bond paper outstanding today comprises US perils (hurricane and earthquake) and therefore offers only limited diversification across peril-regions. And as well within the perils and geographies well covered by cat bonds, additional risk can be accessed in the broader reinsurance market.

To access the broader exposures available in the reinsurance market, it is possible to offer insurers a reinsurance contract whose limit is fully backed by collateral. This is known as ‘Collateralized Reinsurance’. This backing by collateral is the main difference to traditional reinsurance that offers contracts based on a claims-paying rating from one of the rating agencies. To complete such a transaction, a regulated reinsurance entity is required to issue the reinsurance policy to the reinsured and to transform it into an investment product, allowing (i) the investor to pay in the collateral and, (ii) to return the collateral and premium back out to the investor at the end of the reinsurance term.

Collateralized reinsurance can be provided either as a traditional reinsurance, which protects the ‘Ultimate Net Loss’ (UNL) sustained by a reinsured. This means that the actual loss amount incurred by the reinsured, subject to the terms and conditions of the contract, will be reimbursed. In order to evaluate and price such a contract, the portfolio of the reinsured and the risks therein need to be understood in depth. One must understand the monetary impact on that portfolio of each possible event. Another way of providing protection, which has proved popular in the collateralized reinsurance market, is through so-called Industry Loss Warranties, or ‘ILW’ in short. In its simplest form, an ILW contract will pay a loss based on a total market loss to a given event e.g. a US hurricane generating insured losses of greater than USD 50 billion. There are currently two independent agencies which assess and publish market loss figures of large events: PCS in the US and Perils in Europe. ILW contracts provide some advantages over UNL contracts. Firstly, for an ILW the actual portfolio of the reinsured is not relevant, thereby simplifying the analysis and providing little scope for dispute given the independence of the agency providing the loss. Secondly, ILW contracts can be settled relatively quickly, since estimates are factored into the assessment of market damage, whereas an UNL contract requires all underlying claims to be settled before the ultimate reinsurance loss is known and can be paid. This can last several years and is dealt with typically much longer extension periods of individual contracts. From the reinsured’s point of view, however, a UNL contract is a ‘perfect hedge’ whereas the ILW can contain significant basis risk. As such the UNL product is worth correspondingly more and therefore commands higher premium for a unit of risk compared to the ILW.